Has Society Forgotten What Brotherhood Means? The Lost Value of Brotherhood in Greek Life

Photo courtesy of Isabel Qin

Somewhere along the way, fraternities have forgotten the meaning of brotherhood and what it means to be a part of a fraternity. 

When I first arrived in Montreal, I was overwhelmed by the novelty of the city and sheer volume of students. There were times when I felt isolated and yearned for a smaller community that I once had back home. I knew that the Greek life at McGill was lowkey, but had not yet considered rushing; I was afraid of falling victim to the American stereotypes of sororities. However, my human desire for belonging and community overtook my fear. After joining Kappa at McGill, I can confidently say that I have never been surrounded by more passionate, empowering, and well-rounded individuals. The friendships that I have forged have helped shape my university experience for the better. They are deeply rooted in a sense of sisterhood, fueled by love and respect. 

Greek life at McGill

At McGill, less than 2% of students are in Greek life, so no doubt easier to forge more meaningful bonds. “Because we’re smaller and more intimate, we’re able to extract more benefits,” says one of my sisters. 

The race to become “touse” 

Despite my positive experience, I am no stranger to the social valuation system of it all. Contemporary terms like “touse” (top house) and “bouse” (bottom house) have generated clout  in Greek life. Members’ physical appearance and social skills are used to measure the status of both fraternities and sororities, yet there are other differences that distinguish the two groups from each other. While young women are drawn towards sororities that reward emotional vulnerability and honesty with belonging, the opposite holds true for young men.

Fraternities used to be organizations that served as a place to foster lifelong friendships, build social connection and personal development, but are now competing with one another to win the highest social status. The frat crowned with “touse” is usually who the public perceives to be the “coolest,” strongest, and toughest. In other words, whoever is best at performing an idealized version of masculinity. What does it take to build this type of fraternity member? Look no further than the “pledgemaster.”  

The “Pledgemaster”

According to Urban Dictionary, the pledgemaster is “the single most important component of fraternal pledgeship… in charge of the pledging process and all hazing rituals. He is the person responsible for your life long nightmares.” This alludes to the pledgemaster using psychological or dangerous tactics to turn a pledge into the ideal “frat guy.” We’ve all heard the horror stories about pledges subjecting themselves to verbal degradation and physically demanding tasks in an effort to earn the respect of active members. Rather than initiate with genuine traditions, fraternities are testing loyalty with fear, putting a price on brotherhood. 

Sororities on the other hand do not put a price tag on sisterhood: “Kappa doesn’t haze, and it doesn’t make us any less [close].” one of my sisters argues (Arts, U2). This distortion within fraternities reflects something deeper that I believe society needs to rediscover: the idea that friendships should be borne out of vulnerability, not proving one’s strength. So why are fraternities unable to uphold brotherhood to its full extent? “It’s the environment,” one of my sorority sisters says (Arts, U3). “Creating an environment that allows a pledgemaster to have that power might excite him to a certain amount. When people are left to their own devices and access to power… they take advantage,” she says. By placing a new member’s social future in the hands of one individual, fraternities are creating a culture whereby submission and obedience is the key to survival and social status on campus. 

What could fraternities learn from sororities? 

This has proven to be problematic, pushing young men to reach their psychological and physical limits, creating a dangerous environment that divides instead of unites young people. What should be done? There needs to be a universal shift towards upholding the true meaning of brotherhood. Fraternities should run under significantly more campus supervision and actively engage in creating safer spaces where love and respect are reciprocated. The internal hierarchy that establishes a dominant-submissive dynamic needs to be abolished. University, as some of the most formative years in our lives, is already hard enough as it is. Greek life is meant to enhance our experience by playing a positive role in our internal and external growth, helping us find where we belong without having to compromise our values.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *