The Story Behind the Headlines: AI’s Impact on Unemployment

Photo courtesy of Michael Cheng

You’ve probably read a sensationalized headline somewhere in the news along the lines of “AI will steal all of our jobs” or “half of all entry-level white collar jobs will vanish.” However, the real effects of AI on the job market isn’t as drastic as appears and there is far more nuance than reported.

This article discusses what researchers and scholars are seeing currently in the unemployment in our job market, potential risks that are being heavily debated by experts, and what you can do as McGill students to best set yourself up for success in this rapidly changing job market.

What Current Trends are People Noticing?

Over the past couple years, although AI exposure has increased, unemployment rates remained mostly unchanged. According to a publication made by Stanford, over the past 4 years, it was estimated that there was only around a 0.77% increase in the most exposed fields and a 0.85% increase in the least. Numerous other researchers have also reported similar findings and suggest that only around 2.3 to 2.5% of jobs would be at risk if AI adoption continues at its current rate.

What is Being Predicted Right Now?

Although the general unemployment rate for the economy appears small, this doesn’t mean that AI hasn’t been affecting people at all. In many studies surrounding AI’s impact on unemployment, when further segmentation is done, it’s revealed that for recent graduates the unemployment rate is noticeably higher: sources estimate the rate to be anywhere between 5.6% to 5.7%. Many suspect that this is due to the fact that AI is automating entry-level tasks which by effect decreases the demand for entry-level workers. However, it should also be noted that the rise in unemployment for new grads could be due to other factors, such as lingering effects from Covid-19 and rising interest rates. 

Also, as much as AI has been linked to increased unemployment for new grads, some researchers also theorize it may actually increase employment. In many cases, AI has been shown to increase productivity, and may result in lower skill necessary to complete higher level roles. This could potentially increase employment for workers in areas such as software, consulting, and management. Given this, AI could actually increase employment and benefit workers by increasing their productivity.

What Do Researchers Actually Think About This?

To get more insight on this topic, we interviewed Simon Blanchette, a member of the Desautels Faculty of Management at McGill, and a researcher on AI and the future of work.  

With Professor Blanchette, we asked him whether or not the current unemployment statistics were accurate. He replied that “it depends on what you’re looking at.” Further clarifying, “for example, we see a pretty big difference depending on the age group you are looking at; if you want to look at impact, the strongest impact we actually see is for entry level positions.” In fact, later in response to how AI has impacted new grads’ abilities to find a job, he elaborates that data shows employment growth among most other demographics except for new grads and entry-level workers— but AI is just one of the contributing factors.  

However, in terms of widespread impact, Blanchette says “we don’t necessarily see the numbers that are matching the catastrophic headlines.” He adds that the differences between smaller and larger corporations contributes to explaining this: “for smaller organizations, oftentimes AI is mostly used, not for head count reduction, but more for capacity building.” Small businesses are the majority of businesses in Canada and have been struggling with labor shortage for decades. In these cases, AI allows them to increase their efficiency and become more competitive in an already competitive market, especially when we consider that SMEs’ (small medium enterprises) tend to have more limited resources. Blanchette also acknowledges large corporations use AI to reduce headcounts and increase productivity, though this is not proven. Another factor he cites could be that over-hiring during Covid-19 as an outside cause and lay-offs the aftermath of it, as well as other current economic factors. At the moment, researchers are clear that the impacts of AI on jobs are real, but it is a displacement as opposed to a destruction. Managing that transition will be the key, and this will be about upskilling, reskilling, and supporting— to ensure that no one is left behind. 

One final remark from Blanchette, he states,“AI adoption is accelerating in Canada.”[…] Initially we were lagging behind for a long time,”  suggesting that AI adoption in the country isn’t as momentous as some other places.

What can you do as a Student?

 With the increased adoption, AI skills are becoming increasingly valuable. This doesn’t necessarily mean hard technical coding skills, but more transferable skills such as understanding AI and what it can do, identification of opportunities, monitoring, and critical thinking skills around it to use AI responsibly. Learning just a couple could prove helpful. So, here are some ways that you can pick up AI literacy skills as a McGill student to prepare yourself for this changing workforce:

  1. Check out McGill IT Services. McGill IT services links training modules through Mycourses and Agora that teaches you how to use AI responsibly. It also links other helpful sources on how to reference and use AI for research, work, and teaching. Link here: https://www.mcgill.ca/it/ai/build-your-ai-skills
  2. Check out the McGill CDSI workshops. These workshops focus on more technical coding-based, data science skills. They recently launched a new series of workshops for agentic AI in Coding that is open to all students for those who are interested. Check out their workshops here: https://www.mcgill.ca/cdsi/training/cdsi-workshops 
  3. Check out the McGill AI Society. This Society provides a lot of structured bootcamps and conferences as well as other resources from professional organizations that can help you develop solid skills. Check them out here: https://mcgillai.com/

Overall, from what it seems, AI’s effect on unemployment is relatively small, but it is affecting entry-level workers’ abilities to find jobs. What this means is that we’re dealing with a job market that is requiring all of us to adapt; jobs won’t cease to exist, but rather, qualifications may change. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *